The Basic Kalaam Argument
- Whatever
has a beginning has a cause of its existence. (Premise)
- The physical cosmos (=the
sum total of all physical reality) has a beginning. (Premise)
- So,
the physical cosmos has a cause of its existence. (By 1 and 2)
- The cause
of the physical cosmos is not physical (on pain of circularity). (Premise)
- So,
the physical cosmos has a non-physical cause. (By 3 and 4)
The Physics Argument for 2
- According
to our best science, the physical cosmos has a beginning. (Premise)
- What
our best science says is likely true. (Premise)
- So,
it’s likely that the physical cosmos has a beginning. (By a and b)
The Finitism Argument for 2
- There
cannot be an infinite number of items. (Premise)
- If the
physical cosmos has no beginning, there are infinitely many past days.
(Premise)
- So,
the physical cosmos has a beginning.
The Successive Addition Argument for 2
- If an
infinite past is possible, then someone could have been counting down from
infinity and finishing today.
- Necessarily,
if someone were counting down from infinity and finishing today, there
would be no explanation for why they finished today.
- So, an
infinite past is impossible.